Best Butt Plugs for 2019

I picked the best butt plugs for this article based on testing, research and personal experience.

Your first reaction to butt plugs

Popularly known as the last frontier in the human body, the anus is the doorway to a new world of unlimited pleasure. This part of our body is highly rich in nerves, and butt plugs are the key to stimulating them properly.

Thanks to their tapered heads, you can easily insert butt plugs and hold them in place better than other anal toys in the market.

For women, butt plugs can make vaginal penetration more intense if you have sex while wearing one in your anus. The plugs take over some vaginal space, allowing you to feel tighter and more filled. Sounds amazing right? 

Well, besides this, butt plugs are a type of anal toy which men can enjoy just as much, if not even more than women. Butt plugs are incredibly versatile and proper use makes them one of the most powerful sex toys anyone could have in their arsenal. That is the case with both boys AND girls.

Today, I will be looking at the best butt plugs for 2019 which you can use to take your sexual adventures to the next level. But before we get down to it, let’s first get a clear understanding of what is a butt plug.

Oprah Reacting to Butt Plugs
You when you finally try butt plugs

So, What Is A Butt Plug?

While some sex toys have cryptic names, butt plugs are exactly what their name suggests. These sex toys are designed to stimulate your anal muscles by inserting them in the rectum for sexual pleasure. They are somehow similar to a dildo, but they are shorter and have a flanged end to ensure they don’t get lost inside your rectum.

Unlike the vagina, the rectum is a highly delicate part of your body that is easily perforated by sharp objects. For this reason, butt plugs are usually shorter than dildos, mostly ranging at 5-inches long, though they may differ in girth and length. They are also very smooth, which helps avoid bruising your rectum or bowel.

The Butt is Where all the Nerves are at

But, What Does A Butt Plug Do?

While there is a widespread misconception that butt plugs are solely for anal sex preparation, these little toys can do much more than that. For BDSM enthusiasts, they play an essential part in submission and dominance play. As for me, I like my submissives to suck the plug before using it on them. Everyone has their own little fetishes, and experimentation is the key to finding new pleasure.

Butt plugs are also an excellent choice for women who want to enjoy the sensual experience of double penetration with a solo partner.  These toys also allow you to explore new sexual dimensions and get amazing orgasms by simultaneously stimulating your clit with a vibrator or receiving oral, and using a butt plug.

That said, butt plugs also make wonderful masturbation companions. A solo play is a lovely way to explore your anal pleasures while remaining in total control. Some may feel awkward at first, but you’ll easily get comfortable to the sensation surprisingly quickly.

Best Overall Butt Plug: Njoy Pure Plug 2.0

Best Butt Plugs

Price: $149.99 on Lovehoney

If you consider yourself a master of prostate play, then here is your latest challenge. The Njoy Pure extra large butt plug is a girthy, weighty and unbelievably firm sex toy made from luxurious stainless steel. Without a doubt, it’s the overall best butt plug for both men and women. It comes in a curved shape to offer wonderful sensations every time you are using it.

With a bulbous 5.6-inch head and a tapered tip for easy insertion, this butt plug from njoy is comfortable to wear for experienced users. While it’s cold at first touch, the Pure Plug 2.0 will gradually warm to your body temperature. If you are into temperature play, you can put it in the fridge for an enticing chilled sensation. I also like dipping it in warm water for warm sensual pleasure. Here’s what I like about the njoy plug:


• Huge handle to enhance the safety and offer superior control.

• Easy to clean.

• It’s ideal for temperature play.

• Boasts of a large angled head with a tapered tip for comfort.



• Cleaning with an abrasive tarnishes the metal.

• A bit expensive (though it’s worth every penny).

Best Cheap Butt Plug: LuxGem Metal Jeweled

1. Best Overall: LuxGem 4-inch Metal Jeweled Butt Plug

Price: $39.99 on Lovehoney

With a sparkling faux sapphire finish, the Luvgem metal jewel butt plug comes with a cool and weighty metal for intense anal pleasure. It’s easy to plug in, allowing you to enjoy every moment of insertion as you delight in other sensations brought by its body.

 With a tapered shape, I find this butt plug to be quite easy to plug in, while the flared base and slim neck hold it safely in place for hands-free operation. It has an insatiable length of about 4-inches and a 5-inch circumference, making it ideal for butt training and other sexual delights. Here is a quick overview of my feelings regarding this butt plug:


• Its sparkling diamond-like base gives it an elegant finish.

• The tapered shape makes it easy to insert with a bit of lube.

• It’s built with a temperature responsive metal that can be cooled or heated.

• It’s weighty enough for intense anal pleasures.


• It’s not the best butt plug for beginners

Best Couple's Butt Plug: Lovense Hush

Best Couple's Butt Plug: Lovense Hush

Price: $99 on Lovense

Do you like handing over the controls to your partner as you surrender to all his sexual whims? 

Well, the Lovense Hush App vibrating Butt plug is your best bet for this. This teledildonic butt plug is designed to upgrade your sexual experience with interactive fun when having a good time with your partner. The butt plug boasts of a smooth silicone body that emits powerful vibrations for unparalleled pleasure. Additionally, you are free to control the intensity of the vibration using the Body Chat App created by Lovense. This makes the butt plug suitable for use from another room, or even another country. Long-distance sex is easier than ever with this anal toy.

With a generous bulb tapering down a spiral neck, this silken butt plug fits perfectly between your cheeks. Its flared base offers you easy retrieval, while its waterproof exteriors make it ideal for aquatic adventures. As one of the best vibrating butt plugs, it also comes with a rechargeable battery that lasts for up to 2 hours. Aside from a few turnoffs, here is what I like about this Lovense butt plug:


• Great for aquatic adventures thanks to its waterproof construction.

• Smooth silicone material for body-safe use.

• The spiral design traps the lube in for easy retrieval.

• The vibrator is easy to control via the app from any distance.


• It takes longer to charge (2.5 hours)

•  Sometimes the App crashes

Best Beginner Butt Plug: Icicles No 48 Glass Plug

Best Beginner Butt Plug: Icicles No 48 Glass Plug​

Price: $29.99 on Lovehoney

Sleek, petite and pleasurable, the Icicles Glass plug is perfect for beginners and anyone getting ready to some anal action. With its stem base and flower-shaped base, this smooth glass butt plug is carefully crafted to delight your senses during anal play. 

This pink glass plug features an extra long neck and a teardrop bulb for maximum pleasure and comfort during anal play. The decorative flared base limits unwanted movements, while its petite shape makes it ideal for beginners who want to explore anal adventures.  

As the best beginner butt plug, it rocks a hand-blown glass material that’s safe to use with any lubricant for slick sensations.  Here is what I love about this glass butt plug from Icicle:


• The smooth glass material for beginner’s anal play.

• Extra long neck and flared base for prolonged comfortable wear.

• It enhances your pleasure during foreplay sex and masturbation.



• Not satisfying enough for experienced users.

Best Vibrating Butt Plug: OhmiBod Club Vibe 3.OH Hero

Price: $129.99 on Lovehoney

Quiet and lightweight, the Hero remote controlled butt plug is a couple’s sex toy designed to satisfy all your anal fantasies in public. As one of the best butt plugs on the market, this sex toy comes with a remote control that offers three unique modes to allow you to explore epic sexual sensations. 

While it’s made from a smooth silicone material, the Hero butt plug boasts of a curved plug that sits in a perfect arch inside your body to give great excitement. This unisex butt plug also has enough power to vibrate you to orgasmic bliss. Moreover, its rounded, tapered head offers easy insertion and thrilling experience.

Though the Hero butt plug is a little pricey, it’s worth every penny, and all for good reasons:


• Lightweight and quiet for discreet operation.

• Easy to control everything with wireless remote control.

• Smooth silicone material and sleek design for easy insertion



• It’s a bit pricey

Best Splurge Butt Plug: LELO Earl

Best Splurge Butt Plug: LELO Earl​

Price: $1290 on Lelo  or $1990 (for 24-karat gold version)

While it stands out as the most expensive butt plug on this list, the LELO Earl is simply the most distinguished male plug in the world. The butt plug is perfect for the personal indulgence of connoisseurs of male pleasures. 

Available in steel and 24-karat gold materials, this butt plug is thoroughly tested and certified safe for your body. The plug weighs about 221grams and has a 10inch diameter that makes it easy to slide in your butt. Additionally, it comes with a circular base with a handle for easy retrieval.

I would consider a unit like the Icicles No 48 Glass Plug for the money, but here’s why I still like the LELO Earl:


• Sleek stainless steel or 24-karat gold material

• Small and compact size for a smooth insertion

• Refined presentation with matching cufflinks.



• It’s the most expensive butt plug on our list

Weirdest Butt Plug: Fidget Spinner Anal Plug

Weirdest Butt Plug: Fidget Spinner Anal Plug​

Price: $32.99 on Betty’s Toy Box

Do you want an anal sex toy that confuses your nosy neighbors or family members? Try this out!

The Light-Up anal plug is a modern and innovative butt plug that looks like your ordinary steel plug attached to a fidget. The fidget spinner comes with LED lights that light-up your butt, ensuring that your mind doesn’t wander too far. However, you will need three CR1220 cell batteries for the fidget to light up.

Made of stainless steel, this butt plug has the weight and smoothness that you crave in a metal plug. With a tapered shape and 1.3-inches in diameter, the Light-Up anal plug is a must have for beginners. It also offers a wonderful anal sensation to other enthusiasts alike. 

Even better, this premium butt plug boasts a non-porous material that’s easy to clean with some warm water and mild soap. Here’s is why I like about this butt plug despite its few shortcomings:


• Its sparkling diamond-like base gives it an elegant finish.

• The tapered shape makes it easy to insert with a bit of lube.

• It’s built with a temperature responsive metal that can be cooled or heated.

• It’s weighty enough for intense anal pleasures.


• It’s not the best butt plug for beginners

Best Butt Plug for Furries: Blush Novelties Fur Pom Pom

Price: $16.99 on Betty’s Toy Box

If you and your partner would like to spice up your sex life with a cute little butt plug that resembles a rabbit tail, then this is a must-have. The blush Novelties Pom Pom Plugs are great for animalistic fetishes and role-playing. For women, it allows your partner to enjoy watching your pom bouncing while thrusting you from behind.

One thing I like about this plug is the shape. The neck and head of the butt plug are well-shaped to maintain it in position when inserted securely. Even better, the handle is shaped to ensure that this butt plug is comfortable to wear as long as you want. 

While this butt plug is perfect for fetishes, it’s made of platinum cured silicone with no animal fur. This non-porous material makes it easy to clean with water and soap, as well as blow dry the fur. Here’s why this butt plug is part of my anal toys collection:


• Comfortable minimalistic design for easy insertion

• Easy to clean with water and a mild soap

• It’s the cheapest butt plug on our list


• Not ideal for advanced anal enthusiasts

Huge Butt Plug for Advanced Users: Doc Johnson American Bombshell

Best Butt Plug For Advanced Users: Doc Johnson American Bombshell​

Price: $44.99 on Lovehoney

If mega-size portions and super orgasms are your ideal choice in the anal play menu, then this butt plus is here for your needs. It allows you to stretch your butt by filling it with a whopping 9.5-inch girth for advanced anal sensation. 

This girthy butt plug is made with Doc Johnson’s unique formula that makes it smooth and temperature responsive. This sleek and voluptuous butt plug has a tight grip on your ass, and it slides easily in your butt when using an anal lube. 

Additionally, this extra large chap won’t get stuck in your butt thanks to its flared bottom. 


• Extra-girthy plug for advanced anal enthusiasts

• Curved head for intense insertion

• Unique antibacterial formula


• Only suitable for advanced anal play

Butt Plug for Anal Training: Booty Call

Price: $29.99 on Lovehoney

If you are looking to train your butt for some hardcore anal penetration or just for fun, then this nifty number is here for you. Thanks to its tapered shape, the Booty Call Small plug sneaks neatly in your butt and offers a comfortable feel. 

The Booty Call plug is ideal for butt training due to its ability to inflate, pumping its circumference from 4.3 to 8.25 inches.  I find it easy to slide this butt plug in place using a water-based lubricant to give it a smooth feel. 

This plug comes with palm-sized bulb for easy inflation by squeezing it. The sex toy is simple to use, and it’s ideal for amateur anal fans who want to explore larger sizes while being in total control. Here’s what I like about this sex toy:


• It’s easy to insert and use

• It gives you total control while stretching your butt

• Inflates up to 8.25 inches with instant deflation

• Ideal for beginners and experienced anal enthusiasts



• The inflator can get stuck at times.

How To Use a Butt Plug?

Whether you are exploring your anal adventures alone or with your partner, it’s essential that you know how to do it right. That will not only guarantee the safety or your butt during the play, but it will also enhance the experience for maximum pleasure. Here’s all you need to know. 

How To Insert a Butt Plug?

As you will note, butt plugs are quite easy to use, though you end up being hurt if you don’t use them the right way. For beginners, I would recommend using a small toy and gradually increase the size as you advance. Lube is also essential for a smooth insertion while avoiding an injury.

How Long Can You Leave a Butt Plug In Place?

Depending on the comfort of your butt plug, you can leave it in for up to 8 hours. However, like any other sex toy, you only need these plugs when masturbating or when exploring other anal pleasures. I’d also advise against leaving huge plugs in your butt for prolonged periods.

How To Remove a Butt Plug?

Once you are done exploring your sexual adventure, you should gently remove the plug from your butt by pulling the base. Keep in mind that removing the plug too fast might hurt a lot as you may bruise your rectum because of the friction.

How To Clean a Butt Plug?

Immediately after retrieving your butt plug, wash it with mild soap and hot water before you let it dry with air. It’s important to avoid sharing the plugs to minimize the risk of getting bacteria, viruses, and infections. You should also wash your hands after use to avoid spreading anal bacteria to your vagina.

How We Chose Our Top Picks

While choosing the best butt plugs on the list above, we considered some features before picking these sex toys. Of course, you can’t just choose any product available on the market and expect to get what you want.

Before you even start considering the size of a butt plug, it’s important that you consider the material. You can choose any product made of silicone, rubber, and wood, but you should highly avoid products made from phthalates. We also considered the lubricants compatible with each plug –silicon-based and water-based being the most common ones.

Whatever you choose, ensure you carefully go through all the reviews well to help you know what suits you best beforehand. Overall, I like the LuxGem 4-inch butt plug for its elegant finish and intense anal pleasure, but you can also choose any other plug on our list.